Right-clicking on Jordan Gramsey in Providence and selecting “Share Dining Experience” while you have a Full and Fed Up debuff will cause Jordan Gramsey to rate your Gluttony Session Points. If your points are high enough he will put you on his Top Ten Dining Experiences list and award you an Absurdly Large Cookie. If not, he will probably insult you.
An Absurdly Large Cookie can be baked in a Bread Oven to make a Carelessly Burnt Cookie. When baking Foods in a Bread Oven there is a chance for them to become Animal Crackers instead.